Skip to content

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y for Sale in

Buy Online
Buy your next car 100% online through TrueCar+ with transparent pricing, no hidden fees and home delivery
Popular filters
Vehicle Condition
Brand
Otterbein, IN
Value: 75 miles
Min: 75 milesMax: 75 miles
Include non-local listings
Price
Price drop
Condition

Vehicle history data is provided by Experian AutoCheck. Use of this data is subject to the AutoCheck Terms & Conditions.

POPULAR exterior colors
POPULAR interior colors
Body style
Features
Fuel type
Transmission
Drivetrain
Reset all
43 Listings
Clear all

Find a Used 2023 Tesla Model Y in Otterbein, IN

TrueCar has 43 used 2023 Tesla Model Y models for sale in Otterbein, IN, including a 2023 Tesla Model Y Performance AWD and a 2023 Tesla Model Y Long Range AWD. Prices for a used 2023 Tesla Model Y in Otterbein, IN currently range from $19,977 to $49,999, with vehicle mileage ranging from 4,008 to 138,212.

Nationwide Tesla Model Y Listings by Year

VehiclePrice FromCertified Pre-OwnedUnder 100k MilesAccident FreeTotal Available
2026 Tesla Model Y$43,9770 listings24 listings24 listings24 listings
2025 Tesla Model Y$32,9900 listings58 listings57 listings58 listings
2024 Tesla Model Y$25,4880 listings194 listings183 listings195 listings
2023 Tesla Model Y$19,9770 listings513 listings455 listings519 listings
2022 Tesla Model Y$17,9000 listings657 listings569 listings665 listings
2021 Tesla Model Y$13,0990 listings593 listings542 listings642 listings
2020 Tesla Model Y$15,9500 listings201 listings185 listings224 listings