Skip to content

Used Toyota Highlander Hybrids for Sale in

Popular filters
Vehicle Condition
Brand
New York, NY
Value: 75 miles
Min: 75 milesMax: 75 miles
Include non-local listings
Price
Price drop
Condition

Vehicle history data is provided by Experian AutoCheck. Use of this data is subject to the AutoCheck Terms & Conditions.

POPULAR exterior colors
POPULAR interior colors
Body style
Features
Fuel type
Transmission
Drivetrain
Reset all
124 Listings
Clear all

Find a Used Toyota Highlander in New York, NY

TrueCar has 124 used Toyota Highlander models for sale in New York, NY, including a Toyota Highlander Hybrid XLE AWD and a Toyota Highlander Hybrid Limited 4WD. Prices for a used Toyota Highlander in New York, NY currently range from $3,500 to $59,995, with vehicle mileage ranging from 5 to 341,114. If you wish to buy your used Toyota Highlander online, TrueCar has 1 model available to buy from home, allowing you to purchase your Toyota Highlander remotely and have it delivered directly to your residence in the New York, NY area. If you prefer to purchase your Toyota Highlander from a dealership near New York, NY, our TrueCar Certified Dealers have 123 used Toyota Highlander listings available to shop from locally.

Nationwide Toyota Highlander Listings by Year

VehiclePrice FromCertified Pre-OwnedUnder 100k MilesAccident FreeTotal Available
2025 Toyota Highlander$40,94936 listings66 listings64 listings66 listings
2024 Toyota Highlander$28,490187 listings596 listings564 listings596 listings
2023 Toyota Highlander$22,900267 listings1,210 listings1,104 listings1,227 listings
2022 Toyota Highlander$19,991284 listings1,462 listings1,276 listings1,515 listings
2021 Toyota Highlander$18,47781 listings854 listings723 listings941 listings
2020 Toyota Highlander$18,48526 listings334 listings293 listings399 listings
2019 Toyota Highlander$12,9502 listings462 listings421 listings645 listings
2018 Toyota Highlander$13,7620 listings255 listings254 listings411 listings
2017 Toyota Highlander$12,7880 listings149 listings205 listings321 listings
2016 Toyota Highlander$9,9810 listings82 listings141 listings231 listings

Toyota Highlander Owner Reviews

4th Generation Toyota Highlander

2020 - Present
Overall Rating
4.8
10 out of 10
Based on 1,434 Ratings
Performance
4.8
Comfort
4.7
Fuel Efficiency
4.4
Safety Technology
4.7
Features
4.7
All reviews
4.08 out of 10
Performance
4.0
Comfort
4.0
Fuel Efficiency
4.0
Safety Technology
4.0
Features
4.0
Performance
4.0
Comfort
4.0
Fuel Efficiency
4.0
Safety Technology
4.0
Features
4.0
pros
I love how the car drives and handles. It's very roomy and I LOVE the panoramic camera that can also be turned on when moving forward. It makes parking so so easy, it's the BEST!
cons
I would have preferred to have a bench seat in the 2nd row. Unfortunately, in the Hybrid Limited model that is not an option. It would have been had I not gone with the hybrid model. A bench seat would have given me extra seating capacity without taking away space for cargo. In order to accommodate a 5th person, the 3rd row needs to be used. Although the 3rd row is ok for short trip, an adult would not be comfortable in the back for very long and you would lose that cargo space.
Submitted by Lupe H on --- --- ----|2025 Toyota Highlander Hybrid Limited 25th Edition AWD
5.010 out of 10
Performance
5.0
Comfort
5.0
Fuel Efficiency
4.0
Safety Technology
5.0
Features
5.0
pros
Reliability was the #1 factor in my purchase of this vehicle as well as it being a hybrid. I love the gas mileage. I have been driving the hybrids since 2005 when I purchased the Prius, then the Prius V in 2014 and now this vehicle. I like that it has less of an impact on the environment. I love opening the doors with a touch, I like the driver's assist features as well. Using the keyfob to open the trunk, also a favorite. I like the way the car drives. I can't wait for this car to be available as an all electric model.
cons
Visually I feel like I can't see as well in this car as I could in the Prius V and Prius so I rely way more on the driver assist features like the mirror indicator letting me know something is in my blindspot, the warning when a car/pedestrian/cyclist is passing by the rear of my car when I'm ready to back out.
Submitted by Karin E on --- --- ----|2023 Toyota Highlander Hybrid XLE AWD|Purchased on --- --- ----
5.010 out of 10
Performance
5.0
Comfort
5.0
Fuel Efficiency
5.0
Safety Technology
5.0
Features
5.0
pros
Features and handling
cons
4 cylinders
Submitted by Anonymous Author on --- --- ----|2023 Toyota Highlander Hybrid Limited AWD|Purchased on --- --- ----